Wednesday, 12 August 2015

The Effects Of Feminism On Family.



I considered myself a feminist long before it was trendy for men or males to consider themselves as such, long before feminism was fully explored within the South African context. I grew up reading Malcolm X, he placed women on a pedestal and made me worship women. He said, 'you educate a man, you educate an individual but if you educate a woman you educate a nation' that's feminism.

I followed Thabo Mbeki, a lot. I read most of his speeches, he argued that central to the development of our communities is women, that if we don't uplift women we won't annihilate inequality, poverty and unemployment. That's feminism. I am deliberately quoting men to prove that feminism isn't a course that is advocated by women only.

Women's rights are human rights. I come from a Matriarchal family, if there's such, they too instilled in me a sense of upholding women without reserving any sense of negative thought or feeling. They thoroughly inculcated in me a sense of being domestically responsible so that I wouldn't have to put some woman through tedious and arduous chores, unreasonably. So much so I can do any domestic chore, cooking, cleaning, washing and taking care of kids better than many women! And that's fine, isn't that what women feminist are advocating for? Equal share of domestic chores.

So, one time I come out of the closet on twitter and announced that I'm a feminist. I could not believe the backlash I got from 'erudite' women feminists, posing condescending question like 'what do I know about feminism?(I think they confuse it with femininity), in turn accusing me of patronizing them, I was told not to tell women how to be feminist(like they don't ever try to define a 'real man') etc; we live together we naturally influence each other. I should point out here that majority of those in the social media are quasi or pseudo feminists, just from their insatiable need to challenge men at every turn.

Of course, in the heat of the argument/debate I reserved my comments cautious not to fan the burning fires. Mindful of the factual and actual reality that women are suppressed, subjugated and disenfranchised. I truly believe that by natural progression, not influenced by politics or society, women SHOULD be leading ALL spheres of society just from the mere fact that they are in the majority.

So later when things calmed down, I explained my understanding of feminism, which obviously has to do with total emancipation of women in socio-economical and political spheres. Some were more welcoming upon this understanding. The majority were hell bent on challenging a man assuming a stance for a woman's course. Then at this stage I said, I don't think they are true feminist, they are just men-bashers who are set on emasculating and challenging a man at every chance they got! I opened up a can of worms! Least to say, our women need a whole load of healing, and if my utterances helped in defusing their bitterness through expression then I'm a happy man.

But I do still believe there are women, and men, who need to be educated on feminism. Perhaps we should start by calling it Neo-feminism because the old Feminist movement of the 1960s was driven by white women challenging there then status quo dominated by their white male counterparts. The white man, rather the occidental and eurocentric ways, brought reasons for the existence of feminism. The occidental ways steamrolled patriarchy, misogyny and sexism. The ancient African ways had an honorable place for women. This is even documented by Herodatus, 'the father of history', upon landing on African shores he ridiculed, in a report, how African men allowed women to run their economic and trade affairs. So, the modern African man mindset on women IS as a result of colonization after many years of viewing the white man's ways as authority.

Now women demand, rightfully so, their recognition. After years of struggling, the tide is turning. Some women are equal bread winners and upon realizing that they too provide they feel its only fair to tell the man to share domestic chores. Fair. However, I must say that I'm uncomfortable with feminism moving into family spaces. There's chances that we are going against nature. Although I'm great at domestic chores, I believe that nurturing and caring comes natural to women. I believe that if chores are carried out of love and caring then they aren't duties at all.

I also agree that males must pull their weight around the house and define their space and role. However, that must not be pushed by feminism. I'm referring here to a normal affair where there's not any form of abuse. I read my fellow feminist comrade say that patriarchy pervades all spaces, even in romance! Aren't we just shying short of saying 'manhood is a male dominated field'?

The human brain isn't not programed to accept certain man-woman roles if they were to be switched. For instance, and this is proven, if a well off couple has a male general worker at home that does gardening, painting, fixing all things broken etc; and the husband is away all the time engaged in his high paying 'soft skill' work, the wife views the general worker as more manly and masculine than her husband. Vice versa, if they have a maid that does cleaning, cooking, washing, etc; and the wife is consumed by her demanding business trips, the husbands tends to view the maid as a wife material.

I guess its hormonal or physiological beyond societal conditioning.


Feminism isn't a privation of patriarchy.

Doesn't it follow, logically, that if we do away with patriarchy then we must do the same to matriachy? I think feminism should fight misogyny and sexism. And not challenge Manhood at all costs.

Lest, we have a prevalent state where women can't wait to get home and tell their men where to get off in full view of their kids. A few years from now, just as is current case with independent women, men, like me, would have developed good domestic skills and still being providers, they will start wondering what they need a woman for!

Ironically, when eventually manhood and masculinity is diluted and men are emasculated and effemenized or effeminated, it will be the feminist asking where are the 'real' men at.

In conclusion, I know I've said a lot, I guess I'm trying to argue that in attempting to level the life game playing fields, we shouldn't eradicate ALL aspects of patriarchy. There's elements of it that are meant to clarify men roles that we will need for reference.

Thank you for reading,
G.N.M,

5 comments:

  1. "For instance, and this is proven, if a well off couple has a male general worker at home that does gardening, painting, fixing all things broken etc; and the husband is away all the time engaged in his high paying 'soft skill' work, the wife views the general worker as more manly and masculine than her husband. Vice versa, if they have a maid that does cleaning, cooking, washing, etc; and the wife is consumed by her demanding business trips, the husbands tends to view the maid as a wife material. "

    Interesting read overall. I disagree with your statement above completely. The maid and the gardener are fulfilling their job descriptions and this well off couple are not going to take a moment out of their busy schedules to perceive it any other way because of class differences. Doing maintenance work around the house does not necessarily equate to masculinity for a woman - women "these days" have been doing many of the "masculine chores". For some women masculinity is steeped in paying the bills. On the other hand, many well off men do not particularly find housework attractive so eyeing the maid as "wife material" because she cleans the toilet so well is far fetched. Surely, we have evolved in our definitions of masculinity and femininity that we do not hold such base level 1920s views? Or is that the problem you are displaying here, "we" have not?

    "And not challenge Manhood at all costs. Lest, we have a prevalent state where women can't wait to get home and tell their men where to get off in full view of their kids."

    Please define "challenging manhood"? From my perspective a woman who has an opinion which is unsolicited by a man....is challenging manhood. Most men want women to be quiet...cook...clean...raise the kids and live to stroke their male egos. You seem to have elected an example of blatant disrespect rather than a more realistic measured scenario. Telling a man off ....in front of the kids...not only disrespects all present but raises the question of character in the woman displaying such behaviour. The whole premise that women are on some crusade to challenge men is absolute hogwash...we simply wish to exist equally without having our gender brought up to convenience men.

    "After years of struggling, the tide is turning. Some women are equal bread winners and upon realizing that they too provide they feel its only fair to tell the man to share domestic chores. Fair. However, I must say that I'm uncomfortable with feminism moving into family spaces. There's chances that we are going against nature. Although I'm great at domestic chores, I believe that nurturing and caring comes natural to women. I believe that if chores are carried out of love and caring then they aren't duties at all."

    Actually many women are not adept at housework and consider it a painful chore. No, cooking and cleaning is not "natural" to us it is the box that society has painted us into. You are "uncomfortable with feminism moving into family spaces" yet you stated that "So much so I can do any domestic chore, cooking, cleaning, washing and taking care of kids better than many women! And that's fine, isn't that what women feminist are advocating for? Equal share of domestic chores"....so in fact you do not believe that we should have equal share of domestic "love and caring household chores".

    So what are "the men roles that we need for reference" - are those not the very same sexist labels women have been trying to break free from?

    For the record I am not a feminist and I am wary of the aggressive feminist types that abound with complex words on Twitter. Far be it from me to attempt to define you but you may want to redefine yourself as you sir are not a feminist. I think you mean well and you are working on opening your mind to certain ideas. Hence, you come across as contradictory...at least on this subject matter.

    ReplyDelete
  2. are those not the very same sexist labels women have been trying to break free from?Thanks for a thoughtful and not visceral engagement.


    There are roles of nurturing and caring, beyond domestic chores even, that seem to come natural to women.

    I wasn't displaying a class issue. These roles played by maids and gardeners border also on masculine and feminine issues. I was mere stating my point that we still view such roles according to sex. Our brains aren't ready for the big shift.

    Unfortunately, some women feminist don't understand feminism. They think its about emasculating a man at every turn. They don't even know feminist literature or even advocate socio-economic issues. And that's my point. I conced that years of subjugation have elicited this bitterness.

    We are a dual. Naturally. Man and woman. Masculine and feminine. Some roles will be defined as such. It's inevitable. What feminists are right about is shared responsibility, but I do not agree that feminist rhetoric and practice should move into family and marriage spaces.

    There's is an ill-informed and ignorant crusade for men. Lest feminism be perfect.

    You might be right about seeking freedom from sexist labeling.

    Objectivity is subjective. Anything and everthing is defensible. Courts have proved this. Life is fluid, so in some instances we will sound contradictory.

    Thanx once again, miss your blogs ;)

    ReplyDelete
  3. are those not the very same sexist labels women have been trying to break free from?Thanks for a thoughtful and not visceral engagement.


    There are roles of nurturing and caring, beyond domestic chores even, that seem to come natural to women.

    I wasn't displaying a class issue. These roles played by maids and gardeners border also on masculine and feminine issues. I was mere stating my point that we still view such roles according to sex. Our brains aren't ready for the big shift.

    Unfortunately, some women feminist don't understand feminism. They think its about emasculating a man at every turn. They don't even know feminist literature or even advocate socio-economic issues. And that's my point. I conced that years of subjugation have elicited this bitterness.

    We are a dual. Naturally. Man and woman. Masculine and feminine. Some roles will be defined as such. It's inevitable. What feminists are right about is shared responsibility, but I do not agree that feminist rhetoric and practice should move into family and marriage spaces.

    There's is an ill-informed and ignorant crusade for men. Lest feminism be perfect.

    You might be right about seeking freedom from sexist labeling.

    Objectivity is subjective. Anything and everthing is defensible. Courts have proved this. Life is fluid, so in some instances we will sound contradictory.

    Thanx once again, miss your blogs ;)

    ReplyDelete
  4. Society works hard to define men and women as the SAME in that...males are good at X and females are good at Y with no consideration for the fact that we all have different interests and strengths.

    "What feminists are right about is shared responsibility, but I do not agree that feminist rhetoric and practice should move into family and marriage spaces." ....But Gala family and marriage is precisely the place where feminist practice should be applied...perhaps not in their entirety and I am not even certain of what your view on feminist rhetoric and practice is. Oh yes, I recall your view is that it equates to telling a man off in front of their kids - and do you know where you get this idea? You get this idea from the male bashing aggressive feminist types one MAY find on Twitter.

    So family and marriages is where feminist practices need to be applied because this is where it all begins. Remember charity begins at home and we have to raise our children to have character that goes beyond a gender classification. Not sure if what I just said makes sense but I think it does - we need to be individuals and respect one another for our individual characteristics and not assumed group societal characteristics. We must not have our daughters washing dishes whilst the boys sit on the couch scratching their balls playing video games. We must have rosters where our kids take turns to do the household chores WHATEVER they may be.

    Husbands must not speak down to their wives "because they are men". Their sons may witness this and conclude that this is how things are done. Husbands must also have their turn in the kitchen...they must learn to cook. Why wouldn't you want to learn how to cook anyway? Why would you want to be ignorant? My mother left my father after 29 years and after all his girlfriends were gone the poor man did not even know how to make himself a cup of tea. He was alone in a big house sending my sister messages asking her how to make rice. Let's not allow negative circumstances to determine our willingness to learn - let us not be forced to learn. We must have open hearts and open minds.

    Had my father not been sexist and abusive he would never have found himself trying to figure out how to cook rice in his late 50s. He would have known how to do it long before and my mother would have been in the kitchen cooking them a nice meal because she WANTED to.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. You are probably right for certain circumstances and relationships.

      I wasn't made by feminists to be fully and do better in the kitchen, for eg.

      My piece was conceived as a result of a friend talking and crying!*yes men talk* after incidences at home.

      Remember I'm not refering here to abusive relationships. Whether man or woman is abusd.

      I'm still uncomfortable about feminism moving into romantic spaces.

      Delete